Safe Harbour Was a Start. It Was Never Enough.

When the safe harbour provisions came in, the thinking behind them was sound. Directors were being pushed toward premature liquidation by insolvent trading laws that made it dangerous to keep going even when the business was genuinely salvageable. Give them protected room to attempt a turnaround, and fewer viable businesses get killed by caution.

Good intent. Real problem. I supported it then and I support the idea now.

Nearly a decade on, I've watched it work exactly as designed — for a certain kind of company. And I've watched it do almost nothing for the owners who fill my calendar.

What it was meant to do

The provision protects a director from insolvent trading liability while they're developing and pursuing a course of action reasonably likely to lead to a better outcome than immediate administration or liquidation.

Attached to it are conditions. You need to be properly informed about the company's position. Employee entitlements need to be kept up to date. Tax lodgements need to be current. There has to be an actual plan, appropriately documented, developed with proper advice.

Sensible conditions. Nobody wants protection handed to a director who's stopped paying super and stopped lodging.

Why it doesn't reach most owners

Read those conditions again through the eyes of the owner I usually meet.

Their tax lodgements aren't current — that's frequently the first thing to slip. Super is behind a quarter or two. Their books are three months out of date because the bookkeeper was one of the costs that got cut.

Safe harbour requires you to already be in reasonable shape to qualify for protection while you get into reasonable shape. The owners who most need room to move are excluded by the very circumstances that create the need.

Then there's cost. Doing safe harbour properly means a restructuring adviser, documented turnaround planning, and ongoing professional oversight. For a company with real scale and a board, that's a line item. For an owner-operator with eleven staff and a $340,000 ATO debt, it's out of reach — and that owner is the overwhelming majority of Australian business.

The third problem is awareness. I've sat with a great many directors over the years and I could count on my hands the ones who'd heard of safe harbour before it was raised with them. A protection nobody knows about protects nobody.

What's actually missing

Safe harbour treats the problem as a legal-risk problem. For most small business owners, it isn't.

The thing pushing them toward collapse isn't fear of insolvent trading liability. Most have never heard of it. What's pushing them is an ATO debt compounding faster than the business can service, a director penalty notice clock they didn't understand, and nobody in their corner who'll give them a straight read.

Small Business Restructuring was a better-aimed attempt and it helps, where owners find out about it in time and fit the eligibility. Too many don't, on both counts.

What's missing is something that meets an owner where they actually are: behind on lodgements, short of cash, out of their depth, and eighteen months into a problem they haven't said out loud. Protection that starts from that position rather than assuming you've already climbed out of it.

What I tell directors now

I'll raise safe harbour where it genuinely fits, and sometimes it does — it's worth knowing about, and I'd rather you heard of it from me than not at all.

But I don't lead with it, because for most of the people I sit across from it's a door that's already shut. What I lead with is the position: what's actually owed, what's personal and what isn't, which clocks are running, and which options survive.

I'm not a lawyer, an accountant or a liquidator. I coordinate, I strategise, and I connect people with the right help at the right time — working for the owner, not the creditors. If safe harbour is the right conversation, I'll say so and get the right people involved. If it isn't, I'll tell you that instead of selling you a process you can't use.

• Speak directly to Doug: Get help
• Independent bankruptcy help: Resolvency
• Business recovery, SBR and liquidation: Resolve Business Solutions
• Read more insights

No robes. No wigs. Just results.